Dow Chemical Company - how has the stock performed?
By Red Sox Steve

We recently took a look at Dow Chemical Company's business over the last few quarters. We got an idea of what it was up against, what it could control, what it couldn't, and how it survived. Now, let's overlay its stock performance onto the performance of the other Dow (Dow Jones Industrial Average which we'll call "Jones" here to avoid confusion!!), going back 3 years to see what we can discover. I'm taking the figures from Yahoo Finance, so if you want to check my work, they have a great charting function which you can tap in to, for free.

The first thing I notice is that during July 2006, Dow's stock took a hit (about $39 to about $34) while the Jones basically stayed flat. Dow recovered back to $39 by the end of that year, while the Jones continued its upward climb. As best I can tell from reviewing the July 2006 news reports related to Dow, it was a missed earnings expectation that triggered the selling of this company, which was the result of what some thought was increasing oil prices squeezing its profit margins tighter and tighter. That being said, reviewing ALL the news on the company during July 2006, Dow was positioning itself with a Saudi JV, and working on water filtration innovations, which will inevitably contribute to its solid and stable position in the chemical industry going forward. Dow's repositioning could have been the reason the stock recovered in an otherwise difficult short-term environment (high and increasing energy prices as well as a weakening dollar). Furthermore, it has had - and continues to have - a very strong balance sheet.
Fast forward one year to July 2007. Dow reached $47, before literally falling off a cliff while the Jones steadily moved upward throughout 2Q 2007, before they both muddled through the next 3 months. This is a sign that Dow's earnings news did not meet "expectations", as set by market participants in the media and the financial industry. In other words, massive selling which pushed the price down down down was the result of Dow not meeting an artificially derived earnings target, as set by Wall Street financial analysts. Yes, the stock struggled in the 3rd quarter, but this had more to do with the US economy than with the company itself. By July 2007, the severe weakness (housing, jobs & consumer spending) in the economy coupled with ever-increasing energy prices (as well as other raw materials needed by Dow) were enough to scare investors away from this company.
By mid-May 2008, Dow was at its 2008 high of $42. The Jones was also at nearly 13,000 and steady as the summer wore on. From $42, however, this was the beginning of a long slide into 3Q 2008.

In July 2008, as the economic reality of low taxes, high energy prices ($140/barrel), and cheap credit started to slowly reveal itself, Dow, which had taken a severe hit along with the Jones since a year ago, had gone down to $31 (July 15). By mid September, as the financial crisis took hold, Dow recovered to an intra-quarter high of $37. From there, Dow and the Jones performed poorly as a result of the doom and gloom in the global economy and because of a change in the political direction of the United States. Dow went down to $15 right after Christmas, although the market had factored in the Kuwait JV which we discussed last time.
After that, as news of the Kuwaitis backing out of the JV was released, and news of the Rohm and Haas deal being uncertain as a result, the stock went down to $11 at the end of January and $7 at the end of February. Because Dow was able to secure a bridge loan to push the Rohm and Haas merger through and avoid costly litigation with Rohm and Haas shareholders in the process, it has since received a vote of confidence from the market and as of April 22 is at $12.
In the meantime, the Jones in 2009 has lost about 10% of its value since Jan 2. There are little to no signs that the economic recovery is imminent, however, the only signs that things are getting worse are those which were related to the economy created under the prior administration - housing and unemployment.

Let's talk about a couple of other things:
1) Dividend
Looking over the last few years, the most difficult quarter of business (isn't this true for every business?) that Dow had was 1Q2009 - the Kuwaiti deal didn't go through, there was talk of potential litigation if the Rohm and Haas multi-billion dollar merger didn't take place, the global economy was in shambles and a new US president had just taken over. Nightmare scenarios all around! However, with the negative news in the economy having stabilized (don't want to speak too soon, but it's not as bad as it was even 2 months ago), the US economy is at least working on a recovery, as evidenced by the G-20 summit, healthcare reform, tax reform and targeted stimulus spending all taking place. Over the last few years, like many global corporations, Dow had the double benefit of being flush with cash and easily available credit (if needed) AND benefiting from lower corporate and high-income tax rates as well as a lax regulatory environment. It responded by continuing to position itself appropriately through mergers and joint ventures, gaining access to raw materials and leveraging its global reach in the process. There was no sign that the quarterly dividend payment was facing the threat of being cut.
1Q2009 would have been the first time in over 90 years that Dow did not pay a dividend, and this was in the midst of the worst economy we've had in approximately 60 years. In other words, this confluence of events would have been the "perfect storm" that Dow needed to stop paying a dividend... but it didn't. Yes, the dividend was cut from $0.42/share in 4Q 2008 to $0.15/share in 1Q 2009, however it managed to keep its streak alive even in trying circumstances. This stock is a dividend payer, and is proving its quality in the worst economic downturn since WWII.
2) Balance Sheet
In spite of the fact that 2008 was the start of the worst economic crisis in a lifetime, Dow's balance sheet actually improved in a couple of key respects. First of all, it increased the amount of cash on hand, year over year. This was being done in an environment where both cash flow AND available credit were drying up. Second of all, we've got to be impressed with Dow's receivables (what is owed to them by their customers). From 2007 to 2008, Dow's receivables went from almost (approx) $6bn to almost $4bn. In other words, as all businesses were tightening their belts, Dow was able to DECREASE the amount of money it was owed during 2008. This is, in my view, remarkable for any company trying to do business in a deteriorating economy.
Overall, I've got to now do some "off-site" work as I investigate options prices. I have no idea of the costs involved, and, although I want to "go long" at this point, I have to see what options (heh heh...) are available to me to do so. I'll be back on The Ice Flow on Thursday with an overview of the nation that's been providing BMWs and Mercedes for the duration of the 20th century, Germany. See you then!













