By Matthew Storey
Eight months ago, on February 20, Guru published his 2009 Yankee Pre-Season preview, with this;
...'(if) the calamities of early seasons recent don't rear their ugly heads - the Yankees can avoid spotting their rivals the first two months of the season and get off strong early. If they do, and are well positioned on June 1, it should be a magical first season in the new Palace in the Bronx.'

As it turned out, the next few weeks DID produce calamitous events. Alex Rodriguez, fresh from his Steroid funfest had major surgery on his Right Hip and was out for the first six weeks. Mariano Rivera's surgically prepared shoulder did not loosen up right away and he struggled in April until it loosened up. RF Xavier Nady, coming off a huge season and in his contract year, blew out his surgically repaired elbow and was lost for the year. Set-up RH Brian Bruney, coming off a broken foot struggled with his mechanics, hurt his arm and was back and forth all season (he's been left off the ALDS roster, despite his strong September). Worst of all, RH Ace, Chien-Ming Wang, counted on to be part of a dominant Starting Rotation struggled incredibly coming off HIS broken foot, going from 54-20, 3.63 to 1-6, 9.64 and then, just as he was finally looking like the stud of old - blew out his shoulder and may have pitched his last Yankee game.
By May 8, Yankees were at 13-15 and were on their way to being smoked like Sturgeon by the rival Red Sox, who would go on to win the first E-I-G-H-T games in their season series. That 'magical season' already looked iffy...
But Alex came back that day, in Baltimore, and hit the first pitch he saw for a 3 Run HR. New 1B, Mark Teixeira, who had struggled in April, went on a heroic tear and the Yankees had a huge May to make up some of the ground on the Sox. When June 1 did come around, Yankees were actually in 1st Place by 1 game, a lead they'd soon squander as Alex faded from overuse and Wang's struggles continued. They were swept in Boston on June 9-11, and Guru published a column on June 13 'Swept Away! Yankee/Red Sox comparisons' in which, I noted:
'The Red Sox are more competitive than the Yankees will ever be, so are the Angels, the Indians, Twins and Rays. If it was a war, these are the squads like the Confederacy, the Taliban, the Viet Cong, WW II Japanese - dedicated, small fire, innovative, never-say-die...such competitors thrive on close combat, that's why the Mujahadeen are so incensed the Americans don't want a 'fair fight' - they've internalized Western customs that ran from the Crusades to the Victorian Age.
America don't play that.
Neither do the Yankees.
Better resources, better roster, the long slog.
Is there any Red Sox you'd trade for?'
And went on to do a position by position comparison that claimed the 8 times vanquished Yankees actually had more in their dugout and would be likely to reverse the situation against the Red Sox in the coming months, especially since, despite the 8 losses, they trailed by only 2 games in the AL East.
Yankees sputtered for two more weeks, particularly in interleague play, but on June 24, Brian Cashman traveled to Atlanta to see the team and sent a message 'We have all we need in this clubhouse'. Manager Joe Girardi got tossed early, Rookie Catcher Francisco Cervelli slammed his first MLB HR and the Yankees went on a tear.
Coming into the All-Star break, the team sputtered against familiar antagonists, the LA Angels, getting swept in their final first half series to close at 57-41. Yankee hating Universe nodded their heads and said 'solid record, but can't beat Boston OR Los Angeles'. On July 16, Guru published 'Comprehensive 2nd Half Look' in which I noted:
'Yankees have answers at Bat, on the Hill, on the Bases and in the Field and control their own destiny.'
And they did. Beating the Red Sox 9 of 10 second half games to tie the season series at 9-9 after spotting them the first 8, taking 3 of their final 4 from the Angels to tie THAT season series at 5-5 and finishing off a 7-0 season sweep of the other AL Playoff team, AL Central Winner and ALDS opponent, Minnesota Twins. Overall they put up a phenomenal 2nd Half record of 46-18 (.719) to finish as AL East winner and #1 Seed in MLB, 103-59 (.636).
So that was that. Its over.
Onward.
Playoffs beginning as I write, so without predictions about results, I will note my favorites for the various series.
NL
Colorado Rockies vs. Philadelphia Phillies
I despise Dan O'Dowd and the Colorado evangelical emphasis, as regular readers know. I would root for the Iranian team against this bunch. Give me the Phils.
Los Angeles Dodgers vs. St. Louis Cardinals
Manny Ramirez is one of my favorite players of all time, finally free of the 'B' and the creepy supporting cast/fan base - he's easy to root for and Joe Torre is the Godfather of the Yankees, who has removed the LaSorda stench from the Dodger blue and created in its place a dynamic mix of young talent and agreeable veterans.
St. Louis aint my kind of place. Tony LaRussa, brilliant as he is, strikes me as a pompous ass, an 'Anti-Torre' sort (he replaced him in St. Louis), but he has a balanced, brilliant team several notches better than the one he won the World Series with in 2006. Cards can pitch it and hit it and catch it and a case can easily be made for them winning it all.
But not here, I am rooting HARD for the Dodgers/Yankees renewal, a respectful Baseball -only series to echo the Subway series tilts of Torre's youth and bring Brooklyn Joe and Washington Heights Manny back to The Bronx for a love-in/may the best team win sort of affair.
AL
Boston Red Sox vs. Los Angeles Angels
These teams play it differently than Torre/Girardi style. They like to BATTLE (see comments above from earlier in season) and scrap, and tense energy should be in the air. Sox have handled the Angels year after year in Playoffs, so tough to see that changing, but Angels are loaded everywhere and no result would shock. From a Yankee perspective, which Guru, obviously, comes from - give me the Red Sox and let NY avoid the dangerous Angels who've bounced us regularly.
New York Yankees vs. Minnesota Twins
Yankees beat the Cleveland Indians 6 of 6 in 2007 Regular Season and proceeded to get bounced in 4 games. That should take away any complacency against the 0-7 Twins on the Pinstripe part and remove arrogance from even the stupidest Yankee fans (impossible, I know!). Yankees match up well with Minnesota in their lineup, their rotation, their defense and their bullpen. But, as Twins backup Catcher, Mike Redmond noted - they don't play games on Paper (actually, the Twins play on Plastic!). You can break this series down 200 ways, but you won't be able to come up with a statistical basis for a Twin victory. What you CAN note is the Twins have been on a high for the last month of the season, overcoming a seemingly insurmountable 7 game deficit to catch the Tigers on final weekend and then prevailing in last night's thrilling one game, extra-inning playoff. They have momentum and will feed off emotion to balance out disparity in talent.
The Yankees, on the other hand, are a team (as previously noted) built for methodical excellence. They work to channel emotion safely OUT of their play and to focus on taking pitches, grinding through at-bats, making the plays, get 6 solid from starters and shut it down with their bullpen. The challenge from Minnesota will be energetic, they have chippy talkers in Carlos Gomez (who fought twice with Mark Teixeira this season), Alexei Casilla, Denard Span, Delmon Young and Manager Ron Gardenhire...they will take out fielders, strut, chatter, celebrate and try and fluster the Yankees with competitiveness. If they get under Yankee skin and turn it into a fight (the Red Sox, Angel, Ray recipe), they might just have a chance. They have the best player in the AL in C Joe Mauer, a great closer in Joe Nathan, terrific suite of two way players in Span, Cuddyer, Orlando Cabrera (who has beaten the Yankees against big odds as a 2004 Red Sox). Jason Kubel has swung a big bat and the Yankees will avoid Mauer and challenge him to beat them. Twin starters are solid, strike throwers without the dominant Johan Santana and Francisco Liriano of previous Playoff battles.
Yankees can only blame themselves if they lose, as it will come from a loss of composure long before it shows up on the field. Keep their cool, do their thang, ignore Twin chatter and this should be 4 games.
A look at Yankee Players individually:
1. Derek Jeter SS/RH
Derek hit .334 (3rd AL), the 4th best of his illustrious career, made only 8 errors in 150 games (career best) and was the ideal leadoff hitter all season with .406 OBP, 212 hits, 107 runs, 30 stolen bases in 35 attempts and occasional pop (18 HR). Has done it all, seen it all. Nuff said.
2. Johnny Damon LF/LH
Johnny had another big year, but a quiet September. He had a similarly slow July and responded with a huge August, so no reason to doubt his ability if he is feeling well. He's been worried about his future since the 2nd Half started and no doubt the likelihood he is in his last few weeks as a Yankee, where he has expressed a desire to finish his career is/has been weighing on him. But he is well known for being a gamer and a winner, and (if hot) can carry the Yankees. He has power (24 HR) still can run (12 of 12 steals) and will catch it in LF without even a wet noodle for an arm.
3. Mark Teixeira 1B/SH
Best 1B glove I have seen, and Mattingly was incredible. Switch Hitter with huge power. Solid citizen type who loves being a Yankee on the big stage. Tied for AL lead in HR with injured Carlos Pena (39) and led in RBI (122). Tough to really find a weakness in his game and he hit .467 in his only playoff appearance for the Angels last year.
4. Alex Rodriguez 3B/RH
Had the surgery, missed 28 games, sat out for rest another 10 and put up 30 HR/100 RBI while stealing 14 of 16 bases (hello! Hip surgery?) and making only 9 errors all year at 3B. Big arm, huge power, relaxed like never before and hottest Yankee coming into the Playoffs. Unless he chokes on his own expectations, he will dominate modest Twin pitching.
5. Hideki Matsui DH/LH
How great must this guy have been in his prime in Japan? From the moment he got to Yankees, he has done everything right. Now limited to DH by two surgical knees, he gave them 28 HR/90 RBI. Hits RH/LH, Road/Home the same and is a consummate Pro.
6. Jorge Posada C/SH
The feistiest Yankee, whose chippy persona and grumbling about playing time sometimes detract from his incredible production. Came off Major surgery and put up 22 HR/81 RBI in only 383 At-Bats, sluggging .522 at 38 years old. He's as good behind the plate as ever, throwing out 28% of baserunners (twice as good as either Red Sox C, not as good as Mauer). He will bitch about Molina catching Burnett, but will be a vital lineup cog.
7. Robinson Cano 2B/LH
Dustin Pedroia hit .326, slugged .493 and hit 17/83 while playing terrific 2B in '08 and got an MVP, Yankees got more from BOTH middle infielders in '09. Cano hit .320, slugged .520, with 25 HR/85 RBI and a dominant Gold Glove 2B. He is the leading MLB hitter in September/October in the past FIFTY years! (and only 26). He's hot and he's great and he hits 7th in this loaded lineup.
8. Nick Swisher RF/SH
Moved into a starting role when Nady got hurt, Swisher is an average but hard trying RF, but he produces Giambi like Power (29 HR) On-Base (97 Walks) and personality in the clubhouse and with the fans. Like the rest of these guys, he LOVES being a Yankee and it shows.
9. Melky Cabrera CF/SH
The 4th Switch-Hitter in the everyday Yankee lineup, Melky helps make the Yankees invulnerable to pitching matchups. He hit for the cycle in August, hit equally well at home/road, LH/RH and played sterling Defense at all three OF spots. Hits clutch, uses whole field from both sides and can hit LONG HR when overlooked by pitchers seeking a breather from the rest of this gang (had a BLAST in '07 Playoffs off Fausto Carmona). Has GUN in CF to cut down baserunners (through out 4 Indians in 4 ALDS games in '07).
Backups
Jose Molina doesn't hit, handles AJ Burnett extremely well in Game 2.
Brett Gardner hit .270, stole 26 of 31 bases and is a terrific OF.
Jerry Hairston, Jr. plays all positions, knows the game, can run or hit with pop.
Not sure if Eric Hinske (LH power), Ramiro Pena (IF Defense, switch hitter) or Freddy Guzman (pure speed) will be the last guy on the bench.
Pitchers
1. CC Sabathia LH
Ace. Certain. CC pitches deep in almost every start, which becomes a luxury for NY since they feature a deep bullpen. In the playoffs, this should allow them to throw CC for only 6-7 Innings per start, which should free him up for additional starts. When you factor in the extra off-days in playoff series (which is ridiculous since these players are accustomed to playing every day for six months), there is little reason for the Yankees to worry about a 4th Starter even if they make it to the ALCS and the World Series. CC, AJ and Andy are all big, powerful, experienced guys who can go deep and work on short rest. CC has been untouchable in the second half (poor final start against Tampa Bay, however) with a combination of his high '90s heat, wicked slider and terrific change-up. His only vulnerability is a tendency to fly open and leave the fastball high and away to RH hitters (high/inside to LH), when he can't throw the heat for strikes, he has to come in with breaking stuff and change and can give up loud hits. IF the fastball is in the zone, the slider darts out of the zone for swing and miss and the change-up makes 'em shit and go blind.
2. AJ Burnett RH
Ace-like, without the certainty. High '90s fastball? Check. Knee breaking curveball? Check. Stamina, experience, ability to deal with running game (picked off Ichiro twice in one game)? Check. Check. Check. AJ can struggle with his fastball mechanics like CC and when he does, he has a tendency to throw fat, hittable mid-zone strikes that go a L-O-N-G way or walk bushels full of hitters (led AL in Walks). He also gets lazy when he is coasting and can leave pitches in the middle out of nowhere (Porcello did this last night and gave up a HR to Kubel). He also has so much movement on his fastball to LH hitters that it can flow back over the plate for damage. The biggest issue, however, is his composure. Where CC is unflappable in every situation and can control a game with nothing stuff just on his mental command, AJ pouts and turns mild rallies into blowouts at times. Girardi needs to be quick with a chat or even a hook in this circumstance.
3. Andy Pettitte LH
Andy threw the ball better in the 2nd Half then I think anyone in MLB believed he still could. He likes to remind folks that he is 'only' 37, and his 78 K's in 97 2nd Half innings speak to that truth. His cutter has been darting in on RH hitters, his curve has been painting the outside of the plate and he can throw a 4-seamer at times as well. He has unmatched Playoff experience and moxie (trails John Smoltz by 1 win for All-Time record 15-14). He can pitch all day, has the best pickoff move in MLB and is a worthy #3 in a playoff rotation.
Long Men
Alfredo Alceves RH
'Ace' led all MLB relievers with 10-1 record, throwing long, short, spot start (1). He has modest stuff but an endless variety of pitches, all of which he can throw for strikes (16 walks in 84 innings!). He is the ideal picture of composure in all situations on a mound (something young Yankees like Joba and veterans like AJ can learn from, IF they can learn!). Girardi knows Ace will not let things blow up on him, will control damage, will throw strikes, will give him length...not much more you can ask for from a middle guy. A great find by Cashman in the Mexican league, Ace is only 26 and can pitch in MLB as long as he can lift his arm, and probably will be in pinstripes as long as Girardi is.
Chad Gaudin RH
A nice pickup off the scrap heap by Cashman, Gaudin has been a terrific performer for NY since coming over. He has strikeout stuff and limits damage (3.43, 41 hits in 42 Yankee innings). Like AJ, his problem can be control (20 Walks) and he too can then leave fatties in the middle (7 HR). He is deep in the back of pen in a short series, but capable if called upon and earned the spot over longer term Yankees like Brian Bruney.
Middle Men
Phil Coke LH
Coke shuts down hitters (44 hits in 60 Innings) but, stop me if you've heard this...walks too many guys (20) and then gets burned with long balls trying to throw fat strikes (10 HR). He is capable of dominating LH hitters in situational use, but erratic control makes Yankees queasy. 27 and homegrown with a chance to be a Yankee for a long time.
David Robertson RH
Robertson is a strikeout machine, leading ALL AL Pitchers with 13 K's per 9 Innings (63 in 43.2 IP), like Coke he walks too many (23) but does not surrender the long ball (4). He had some arm fatigue late in September, which would be the only worry about this terrific young pitcher. Another homegrown mid '20s guy who, like Coke, was a minor league starter with several pitches and can give length if called upon.
Late Innings
Joba Chamberlain RH
Joba was erratic in the last two months after being dominant first three starts of the second half. He struggled with his fastball command, his control and his concentration at times as he moved in and out of various schemes the Yankees devised to limit his innings. His velocity, 101 MPH two years ago, was at 91-94 for most of his late year starts, which probably indicates a bit of fatigue in his first full year as a starter. But he dominated Boston in several starts (including next to last of the year) and will be asked only to air it out as a reliever in the playoffs, which he did in blowing away Tampa this weekend with a 7 pitch inning at 97 MPH. He gives the Yankees an incredible 7th Inning asset, especially with the depth of this pen. Can obviously give multi innings, but unlikely to be asked to do that with all the other options for length. Joba is homegrown and just turned 24.
Phil Hughes RH
Phil had finally found himself as a Yankee starter this June, when Chien-Ming Wang came back from rehab stint and reclaimed his spot in rotation. Yankees put Hughes in the Bullpen and no single move had more to do with the 103 win season. Hughes was Mariano-like in the 8th Inning, striking out 65 to 13 walks and a 1.24 ERA in relief. Another homegrown power pitcher, Phil is 23.
Mariano Rivera RH
Talking about Mo's surgery in the February preview, I noted that even if he fell off 'by 20%, his ERA would only be 1.68'. Mo fell off by less than 20%, saved 44 of 46 chances, struck out 72 to 12 walks and his ERA did 'soar' all the way to 1.76! The only knock on his season was an uncharacteristic spate of HR's (7 in 66.1 IP, the worst of his career). Mo is the all-time Postseason closer with an absurd 0.77 era and 34 saves, but he has also been the victim of some memorable Postseason comebacks (Cleveland '97, Arizona '01, Boston '04).
Guessing the Yankees will take their chances on him, however.
And that's that. 35 minutes to first pitch, enjoy the Yankees in ALDS, we'll update after its over.